Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Changing the Nonprofit Corp Law in NY: Let’s Try to Get it Right the First Time...



It was clear from yesterday’s Senate Hearing held by the Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions (in which I testified) coupled with the fast & furious press releases that preceded and followed it, that  a full court press is underway to get the Attorney General’s Bills reforming the State’s Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (S-5198A/A-7337)  and regulating executive compensation, passed this session (meaning by mid-June.) These Bills are revised versions of a single Bill introduced last session.
There is plenty of confusion going around as the AG’s Bills were introduced very recently amid a flurry of other activity. Case in point - an alternative, yet very similar Bill was introduced before the AG’s version by the New York State Law Revision Commission (S-3755-A). Yet another Bill targeting paid board members and board nepotism ( S-5315) was introduced in the past couple of days. And finally, a NYCON backed Bill (A-2118) is in the mix. This Bill is focused largely on executive compensation and conflict of interests matters and was sponsored by Assemblywoman Amy Paulin, a former nonprofit executive, and was reintroduced months ago.

One of the wildest justifications for reform made by the AG was that we need to have a “friendlier” environment for nonprofits to incorporate in our state – that we need to make the process easier and faster.  In essence, that the 103,000 nonprofits we have in this state are not enough and I guess the fact that the AG’s Office does not have the capacity to adequately enforce current law for the nonprofits that already exist, let alone efficiently process the current workload of corporate changes in a timely way, is irrelevant.  
As I testified, there are thousands of nonprofit corporations that are not currently functional and exist  simply because of the burdensome costs and processes of dissolving or merging.  I know of very few in the sector, including funders, who believe we have a problem of too few nonprofits.  What we want is stronger, more capable nonprofits - not more.
Another rather strange twist was that Senators Ranzenhofer and Marcellino asked Susan Hager of the United Way of NYS  whether prompt contracting and payment provisions should be included in the Bill. She testified that she was opposed to the addition because it would likely delay passage.  I can state emphatically that nonprofits care a whole lot more about  contracts and payments then they do about corporate reform.   

So, what is going to happen?
The political process is gearing up and there are more hearings to go. Chances are that a bill will get passed this session, but hopefully not one on executive compensation. Negotiations are going to occur with the Law Revision Commission, the AG and Senate staff, so I predict that we will see changes from what the AG proposed.

My preference is that we get this right the first time rather than rush it through the legislative process.  I would love to see prompt contracting and payment legislation added and if it means waiting until next session to get it through – then let’s go for it. Adding to this the corporate reform legislation may very well make it more likely to pass sooner. 
If, after all these years, nonprofits lived under an archaic set of confusing and non-productive laws, we can certainly wait one more legislative session for comprehensive reform that is sustainable and works; reform that focuses on getting the State of New York to honor its financial obligations to nonprofits more than on creating bureaucracies and processes to monitor compensation decisions where so-called “excess” does not even remotely exist.
This is the time. We have everyone's attention. "Good enough" isn't good enough for our sector, our community and the people we serve.

If we're going to do it right now, let's make sure we do it right.


- Doug Sauer, CEO, NYCON