Monday, February 9, 2015
Monday, January 13, 2014
Despite the Silence, there is Opportunity...
I had hopes and expectations based on sources that the
Governor would have taken the opportunity to lay
out the need for a coherent public policy that would promote the economic, social, cultural and environmental value
of nonprofits in our communities and the importance of a
positive State-Nonprofit Sector partnership.
This has been a tough regulatory, procurement and prompt payment
year for nonprofits and some positive words from the Governor would have gone a
long way.
Doug Sauer, CEO
New York Council of Nonprofits
January 10th, 2014
To me, the silence on nonprofit issues during the address was deafening, especially when an overall
policy framework was being set forth that can have
relevance and a positive impact on our
sector. (We did find out that nonprofit initiatives were mentioned briefly in the full "State of the State" booklet on page 172 here.)
Consider these few examples:
- When heralding the tremendous growth in private sector jobs, no mention was made that this growth in the private sector included nonprofit jobs. In 2010, nonprofits jobs made up 18% of the entire private sector in the state representing 1.25 million workers and a payroll of $57 billion. The opportunity was there in his Address to recognize our tremendous and vibrant contributions to the economic fabric and recovery of our state and local communities.
- When talking about the need for and plans to deregulate for-profit businesses so that they can grow and thrive, no mention was made of doing the same for nonprofits. Over-reaching and burdensome regulations and bureaucratic hurdles weakens our fiscal health and our job creating abilities, much less our mission work. The Governor through standardization of contracts, the Gateway Grants Initiative and signing of the Nonprofit Revitalization Act, has established a policy direction intended to alleviating unnecessary burdens. The opportunity was there to reinforce that intent. Like the for-profits, we need responsible deregulation in order to improve our business models and bottom lines.
- When highlighting the successes of the Regional Economic Development Councils, no mention was made of the successful nonprofit led initiatives or the hundreds of thousand dollars of investments that have made in these projects by local organized philanthropy. Nonprofits bring creative ideas and resources to the private sector table and our efforts deserve recognition.
- When emphasizing the importance to financially incentivize teachers to “pay them like professionals,” no mention was made of the wage deficit for our nonprofit workforce. For some reason, Sate contracts treat us as a “third sector” when it comes to compensation. Our professional workforce, despite its ever-increasing qualifications, high level of expertise and outstanding performance in the most difficult of circumstances, are paid much less than comparable public and for-profit employees. The policy and media obsession with the potential of excessive compensation among an elite few is a straw man argument that diverts attention from the overall reality of nonprofit workforce compensation. Like high performing teachers, a nonprofit policy is needed for government contracts that encourages and rewards professional excellence.
It is clear that the value and
importance of our industry and work needs to be reflected in the State’s
economic policy and that the many myths and misperceptions that exist need to
be corrected. The Governor’s State of the State Address has laid out the
ground work that now provides us with the context, economic principles
and opportunity to educate policymakers about our business realities and our true
impact on the state’s economy. Over the coming year and
beyond, NYCON, with help from our members,
is looking forward to improving the nonprofit partnership with the State of New York.
Doug Sauer, CEO
New York Council of Nonprofits
January 10th, 2014
Wednesday, October 16, 2013
Where is the love?
Where is the Love
by Doug Sauer, CEO, NYCON
I just
read an article in the Nonprofit Times
by Thomas McLauglin entitled “Government
Loves You”, in which the author attempts to make the argument as to how
much government trusts and relies on our sector.
Ironically, last week at our Camp Finance conference and before I read the artlice, I asked the audience during the panel on state government
relations “Are we feeling the love yet?
The
response back was surprisingly strong. Views were stated that the State of New York may be “intentionally” trying to put some nonprofits, particularly the
smaller ones, “out of business.” Folks expressed the feeling of being continuously “assaulted” by critical
rhetoric, seemingly endless confusing, unnecessary and costly regulations that create more "gotcha hoops to jump through",
and financially strangled by chronic late contracts and payments.
My initial response to the audience was that I did not believe this was all part of an intentional effort. I went on to explain that policymakers, state agencies and regulators are not as knowledgeable as they think they are as to how we truly operate and the impact of their actions. They tend to see us through the lens of government's needs to regulate and control, not our need to serve mission. I observed that the State often views us as "extensions" of government rather than as private sector organizations that may partner with government. This view is evident by the constant push for us to function more like government; making us more inefficiently bureaucratic, compliance and CYA oriented; slow to adjust to market forces; and resistive to change and innovation. The one exception is that we are suppose to do the job cheaper by compensating our workforce significantly less than state employees; so much for all diverted attention to excessive compensation of a few executives.
The other contributing factor to the problem that was acknowledged in the discussion was the fact that we have 3 elected officials – the Governor, Comptroller and AG, all doing their own regulatory and procurement thing to our sector. There is no common or coordinated policy framework among them regarding our sector, ittle constructive communcation, and lots of finger pointing when it comes to late contracts and payments. Nonprofits end up being the collateral damage of all this..
I realized in the panel discussion that I needed to backtrack some on saying there was no intentionality by acknowledging that many state agencies are looking to reduce the overall number of contracts that they manage, given their own shrunken workforce, and that there is the intention to use rate pressures to force “scale” to be achieved among Medicaid-funded providers.
There is no question that community-based nonprofits are feeling beleaguered, used, not heard, and financially strapped. The frustration and anxiety amongst our ranks is rising greatly over our sustainability to impact mission. It is getting harder and harder in this environment for us to attract and inspire an under-paid and unappreciated workforce. The same is true for volunteer board leaders who are expected to invest their time, talents and wealth in matters of compliance rather than mission while assuming increased personal liability risks.
I, like my colleagues in New York, am not yet “feeling the love” that McLaughlin believes is there.
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
Changing the Nonprofit Corp Law in NY: Let’s Try to Get it Right the First Time...
It
was clear from yesterday’s Senate Hearing held by
the Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions (in which I testified) coupled with the fast
& furious press releases that preceded and followed it, that a full
court press is underway to get the Attorney
General’s Bills reforming the State’s Not-for-Profit Corporation Law
(S-5198A/A-7337) and regulating
executive compensation, passed this session (meaning by mid-June.) These Bills
are revised versions of a single Bill introduced last session.
There is
plenty of confusion going around as the AG’s Bills were introduced very
recently amid a flurry of other activity. Case in point - an alternative, yet
very similar Bill was introduced before the AG’s version by the New York
State Law Revision Commission (S-3755-A). Yet
another Bill targeting paid board members and board nepotism ( S-5315) was introduced in the past couple of days. And
finally, a NYCON backed Bill (A-2118) is in the mix. This Bill is focused largely
on executive compensation and conflict of interests matters and was sponsored
by Assemblywoman Amy Paulin, a former nonprofit executive, and was reintroduced
months ago.
One
of the wildest justifications for reform made by the AG was that we need to
have a “friendlier” environment for nonprofits to incorporate in our state –
that we need to make the process easier and faster. In essence, that the
103,000 nonprofits we have in this state are not enough and I guess the fact
that the AG’s Office does not have the capacity to adequately enforce current
law for the nonprofits that already exist, let alone efficiently process the
current workload of corporate changes in a timely way, is irrelevant.
As
I testified, there are thousands of nonprofit corporations that are not
currently functional and exist simply because of the burdensome costs
and processes of dissolving or merging. I know of very few in the
sector, including funders, who believe we have a problem of too few nonprofits.
What we want is stronger, more capable nonprofits - not more.
Another
rather strange twist was that Senators Ranzenhofer and Marcellino asked Susan
Hager of the United Way of NYS whether prompt contracting and payment
provisions should be included in the Bill. She testified that she was
opposed to the addition because it would likely delay passage. I can state
emphatically that nonprofits care a whole lot more about contracts and
payments then they do about corporate reform.
So, what is going to happen?
The
political process is gearing up and there are more
hearings to go. Chances
are that a bill will get passed this session, but hopefully not one on executive
compensation. Negotiations are going to occur with the Law
Revision Commission, the AG and Senate staff, so I predict that we will
see changes from what the AG proposed.My preference is that we get this right the first time rather than rush it through the legislative process. I would love to see prompt contracting and payment legislation added and if it means waiting until next session to get it through – then let’s go for it. Adding to this the corporate reform legislation may very well make it more likely to pass sooner.
If,
after all these years, nonprofits lived under an archaic set of confusing and
non-productive laws, we can certainly wait one more legislative session for
comprehensive reform that is sustainable and works; reform that focuses on
getting the State of New York to honor its financial obligations to nonprofits
more than on creating bureaucracies and processes to monitor compensation
decisions where so-called “excess” does not even remotely exist.
This is the
time. We have everyone's attention. "Good enough" isn't good enough
for our sector, our community and the people we serve. If we're going to do it right now, let's make sure we do it right.
- Doug Sauer, CEO, NYCON
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)